What is the ‘manosphere’?

A boxer is sitting on a stool in the boxing ring, wearing boxing gloves, and behind the ring stands his wife with her hands on his shoulders
Boxer in the ring with his wife, 1963, photographer: Henk Blansjaar, Spaarnestad Photo via the National Archives

From fitness advice and dating tips to financial independence and rigid gender roles: online, young men are increasingly being targeted by influencers who tell them what it means to be a ‘real man’. Some of this content is created by manfluencers who capitalise on insecurities and frustrations surrounding masculinity, relationships and their place in society. In doing so, women and feminism are regularly singled out as the cause of societal problems. But what exactly is the manosphere? Why is it appealing to young men, and how is masculinity used as a revenue model?

What is the manosphere?

The manosphere is not a clearly defined or uniform movement, but a heterogeneous online ecosystem with diverse ideological beliefs, themes and degrees of radicalisation. Central to many of these strands is the belief that men are disadvantaged compared to women in contemporary society, and that they must reclaim their lost position, power or status.

Research by Argos and De Groene Amsterdammer shows that there is not so much a separate ‘manosphere island’ as a broad online ecosystem of so-called ‘manfluencers’ who present themselves as coaches, entrepreneurs, personal trainers, or spiritual or psychological mentors. However, a common message runs through the diverse topics covered in the manosphere: men are portrayed as natural leaders and protectors, whilst women are depicted as emotional, dependent and ultimately subordinate to men.

Masculinity content versus ‘manosphere’ content

Masculinity content refers to online content in which ideas, norms and expectations regarding masculinity are presented, discussed or reproduced. This content often centres on characteristics such as physical strength, financial success, heterosexuality, self-reliance and emotional control.

‘Manosphere’ content forms a specific subcategory of this broader masculinity content and comprises a collection of online communities and influencers who disseminate sexist views on masculinity, femininity and gender relations.

How did the manosphere come about?

Although the manosphere is nowadays mainly associated with social media, some of its key roots lie in the men’s liberation movement of the 1970s. With the rise of the internet, from the 1990s onwards – and particularly from the 2000s – these ideas began to take on greater form and diversity within online communities and forums.

Whilst the men’s liberation movement initially drew attention to the ways in which traditional gender roles also restricted men, various strands gradually emerged, including groups that claimed feminism was responsible for many of the problems men face today. This development gave rise to a collection of partly overlapping online communities, which are often regarded as the five main original ‘hubs’ of the manosphere:

  • Men’s Rights Activists

  • Men Going Their Own Way (MGTOW)

  • Pick-up artists

  • Traditionally conservative and Christian men’s groups

  • Gaming and incel communities

The term ‘manosphere’ first appeared online around 2009 and was used to describe the many blogs, forums and platforms where men exchanged experiences, frustrations and views on their position in society. Since then, the manosphere has evolved from a relatively fragmented collection of niche communities into a much broader online ecosystem, in which ideas about masculinity, relationships, success and gender reach a growing audience via influencers and algorithmic recommendation systems.

What makes the manosphere appealing to young men?

The appeal of the manosphere lies largely in the fact that it addresses the genuine questions and insecurities of young men. During the process of identity formation – particularly in adolescence – many boys seek guidance, recognition and practical advice on matters such as money, dating, mental health and appearance. Both creators of general masculinity content and ‘manfluencers’ capitalise on these insecurities. Particularly within the manosphere, simple solutions are often linked to specific ideas about gender relations.

Much of the advice shared in this online content is not problematic in itself, such as eating more healthily and exercising more. However, the way in which this advice is embedded within broader ideas about masculinity, success and gender relations can be problematic. Manfluencers also often promote an idealised image of success, in which entrepreneurship, high-risk investing, cryptocurrency, share trading and financial independence are presented as achievable paths to it. Masculinity influencers showcase luxury cars, villas and an exclusive lifestyle as proof that financial success is attainable, provided one possesses the right discipline, mindset and work ethic.

When these goals are subsequently not achieved, the manosphere offers a misogynistic explanation. This attributes the disappointment of failing to achieve success to women and feminism, rather than to economic and social circumstances.

Masculinity as a revenue model

Feelings of insecurity, loss of status and questions of identity amongst men are regularly exploited within the manosphere as the basis for commercial revenue models that have become a multi-billion industry.

Social media platforms do not merely function as neutral content channels in this context, but play an active economic role. Algorithms reward content that evokes strong emotions and generates attention, meaning that messages which capitalise on frustration and resentment achieve a wider reach. This creates an economic system in which both influencers and platforms profit from masculinity.

The manosphere and the anti-gender movement

The manosphere also overlaps with the so-called ‘anti-gender movement’. This international movement, which essentially consists of a coordinated network of organisations, opposes gender equality and diversity. The pejorative umbrella term ‘gender ideology’ is used by the anti-gender movement to describe emancipatory developments relating to the changing of gender roles and the acceptance of the gender-diverse LGBTI+ community. The impact and success of this movement, and the framing it employs, are evident in the way in which the issues it opposes have been politicised on an international scale, including the societal acceptance of transgender people.

Conclusion

The manosphere is more than just a collection of online communities with strong views on masculinity. It is a broad ecosystem in which social uncertainties, traditional gender roles, anti-feminist beliefs and commercial interests converge. Its appeal cannot be separated from the questions and problems that young men actually grapple with. By offering a sense of recognition, simple solutions and an idealised image of success, influencers are able to link these vulnerabilities to a message in which women and feminism serve as scapegoats. At the same time, they profit from the insecurities they tap into. The manosphere therefore demands attention not only for the ideas it disseminates, but also for the role of influencers, revenue models and social media platforms in amplifying their reach and influence.

Subscribe to our newsletter